Hamburg is packed with good cafés. Some days, it feels as though almost every corner has at least two places where you could happily sit down: one serving excellent cakes, another where you could settle in for a leisurely lunch or spend a few hours over brunch with friends. For me, however, choosing one is not always quite that simple, and it has very little to do with being spoilt for choice. Coeliac disease and lactose intolerance narrow the field considerably, which means that whenever I arrange to meet someone for coffee or food, I normally do my homework first.
That works perfectly well until I suddenly get hungry, with no time to plan anything in advance. Once I reach the point where I can barely see straight and am becoming increasingly irritated with the world around me, sensible decision-making is not exactly my strong suit. Standing somewhere in Hamburg, hungry, scrolling through Google Maps is not my favourite pastime either. Luckily, on a rainy February morning that had begun with a blood test, I found Café Mama Silvia fairly quickly. It was such a successful accident that I returned later that same week. Schwarzenegger had a point about coming back, although my second visit involved considerably less property damage.
Rain outside, breakfast inside – and, on my first visit, almost the entire café to myself
I had naturally needed to arrive for the blood test on an empty stomach, so by the time I emerged, I was not in the mood for an extensive comparative study of Hamburg’s breakfast options. I wanted food, preferably accompanied by coffee. Café Mama Silvia was only a few minutes away, the reviews looked promising, and a quick look at the menu gave me the two pieces of information that mattered most at that particular moment: gluten-free bread was available, and so was coconut milk for my coffee. The latter was especially welcome because oat milk, despite being the default plant-based option in many cafés, is not automatically gluten-free and therefore does not always solve the problem for me. That was quite enough research for one hungry morning. I closed Google Maps and headed over.
Inside, I almost had the place to myself. Rain was falling beyond the enormous street-facing window, while plants, wooden surfaces and warm lights made the café feel particularly inviting on such a grey morning. There were so few other customers that I could actually take the place in rather than simply sit down, eat and leave. By the time I finished breakfast, there were perhaps two other occupied tables. Service was quick and friendly, I barely had to wait, and someone came back during my meal to ask whether everything was all right and whether I was enjoying the food. It is a small thing, but I appreciate places where hospitality does not end with putting a plate on the table and reappearing when it is time to pay.
I order a latte almost everywhere, and saw no compelling reason to reinvent myself here, so I had one with coconut milk. Plant-based alternatives can occasionally take over to such an extent that I end up feeling as though I am drinking the milk rather than the coffee, but this one blended into it remarkably well. The coconut was not overpowering, nor did it make the drink feel heavy. I usually take two or three sugars in a latte; I barely added any to this one. For me, that says quite a lot.
For breakfast, I chose the Bio-Rührei with gluten-free bread and added salmon and avocado. On the menu, the original version comes with homemade purple sourdough bread, red Ají Panca pesto, chives and salad; in my case, only the bread was swapped. Better still, the gluten-free version did not feel like the obligatory substitute sitting sadly at the edge of the plate. It was genuinely good, and together with the eggs, salmon, avocado, salad and pesto made for a fresh, warm and properly flavourful breakfast. It filled me up without feeling heavy, and twenty minutes later I was not wondering where I could go to have an actual breakfast. And yes, I have had breakfasts after which that has happened.
Where Peru comes in
The Ají Panca pesto was the first clue that Mama Silvia approaches breakfast a little differently from the average Hamburg brunch spot. The dishes themselves are often familiar, but Peruvian ingredients and flavours keep finding their way in: Salsa Huancaína with the Benedict, empanadas, Chicha Morada, and the distinctive purple sourdough bread. Rather than having a clearly defined ‘European’ side and a separate ‘Peruvian’ one, the two seem to flow into each other, making even familiar starting points such as scrambled or poached eggs rather more interesting.
There is also an actual Mama Silvia behind the name. Silvia is the mother of the man who runs the café, and in a promotional introduction to the place, the food is described as a modern interpretation of Peruvian family recipes. That does not mean every dish on the menu should be imagined as having travelled directly from a family recipe book, nor does the story need embellishing beyond what is actually there. I found it much more interesting to see how that background translated onto the plate. I did not need to know what Ají Panca was before tasting it for the pesto to work, and I did not have to order a designated ‘Peruvian experience’ to become curious about the rest of the menu.
The clearest indication of what I thought of that first breakfast is that I booked another table before the week was over, this time with a friend and Susi. I wanted to show them the place, and it seemed an obvious choice for a weekend brunch together. We booked online and later received an email confirming a slight adjustment to our reservation time. I also used the exchange to ask whether Susi could come along. They kindly confirmed that dogs were welcome, so at least that part required no further logistical operation.
When I returned, however, I found an entirely different Mama Silvia. The almost empty café of that rainy weekday morning had been replaced by a full house, plenty of noise and people sitting rather close to one another. We ended up further inside, in a corner near a radiator, which actually worked rather well for Susi, but the combination of noise and proximity quickly became a little much for me. My friend was left with a backless stool, while I spent the next couple of hours on a bar stool. I fully understand the economics of fitting as many seats as possible into a small café; a few generously sized armchairs would probably halve its capacity. My back, unfortunately, remains unconvinced.
The full house naturally affected the pace as well. The staff remained just as friendly, but our food took considerably longer to arrive than it had on my weekday visit – and time has a remarkable tendency to move more slowly when one is sitting on a bar stool in a noisy room. Once our order arrived, however, there was nothing about the food itself to suggest that the café was packed.
This time I chose the Benedict Andino Royal: two poached eggs with salmon and a spicy Salsa Huancaína, accompanied by salad. My friend ordered a version of the Bio-Rührei I had eaten before, while we switched from lattes to cappuccinos, if only to preserve a small degree of unpredictability. What I particularly liked about the Benedict was that the Huancaína did not feel like something added simply to make the dish seem different; it just worked with the eggs and salmon. The flavours made sense together, nothing seemed out of place, and the portion was actually rather large for me, so getting through it took a while. The wait had been longer, but the breakfast was every bit as good as I had expected after my previous visit.
Susi, meanwhile, had identified an entirely different flaw in the weekend brunch arrangements. She normally joins us at table height, but on a morning when there was barely enough room for the human customers, we did not feel it would be particularly reasonable to request additional seating for the dog. This change in arrangements had not received Susi’s prior approval.
The café itself had no problem with her. She was welcomed kindly, and when we asked for some water, they brought her a bowl. Susi was rather less enthusiastic about the concept of remaining in her bag. She climbed out, looked around, made several attempts to assess the café’s social and culinary landscape, and periodically returned to us. At times she seemed more uncertain than curious, although her interest in anything edible remained reassuringly consistent. There were a few slightly puzzled looks from neighbouring tables, but nobody said anything; inevitably, though, I had to keep an eye on her, which made my own breakfast rather less peaceful than the first one had been. What I learnt was not that Mama Silvia and dogs are a bad combination, but that a packed weekend service is probably not the best one for Susi and me.
Next time, I will check the time
Almost everything that was not on the plate changed between my two visits. On one occasion, I sat by the window on a quiet, rainy morning, with quick service and an almost empty room around me; on the other, there was barely a spare place, the noise level was considerably higher, and we waited much longer for our food. I enjoyed breakfast both times, though, and ultimately that is the part of Mama Silvia that makes me want to return.
I will probably give the weekend rush a miss next time. Not because I was surprised to find a popular café busy, but because I now know that I enjoy this particular place much more when there is a little room and calm around me – and with Susi, that matters even more. In warmer weather, the terrace may change the equation somewhat, although I have not yet tried it myself.
The whole thing had begun with much smaller ambitions. After a blood test, I simply wanted breakfast and coffee somewhere nearby without having to compromise on one of them because of my dietary restrictions. Café Mama Silvia solved that problem rather quickly. Next time, I will not need Google Maps – I will just have to pay a little more attention to the clock.
Café Mama Silvia
Address: Winterhuder Weg 65, 22085 Hamburg
Opening hours: Monday–Saturday 9 am–5 pm · Sunday 9 am–6 pm
Reservations: Available online; particularly worth considering for weekend brunch.
Dogs: Welcome — I confirmed this directly with the café before my visit.
Café Mama Silvia – official website
Instagram @cafemamasilviahh
Opening hours and menus may change, so check the café’s website before visiting.
Leave a comment